Every piece of millwork and fireplace, every detail, was left intact,” recalls Rodney Lawrence of the Bedford-Stuyvesant brownstone that he and his husband, Terry Sonterre, bought in 2005 and have been slowly renovating ever since. The couple had been living in a cramped rental in the West Village and looking for a house, and they were ready to give up on finding anything that hadn’t been denuded of character by a bad renovation when they walked into this place. The sellers had 25 offers, but they prevailed: “We were the first people here, and we were the last people here,” Lawrence says.
The move, and the incremental restoration of the place, coincided with Lawrence’s own reinvention as an interior designer. His family had decamped to Montclair, New Jersey, from Trinidad in 1980, and “I never thought of design as a profession growing up, because every first-generation-immigrant child — every parent wants you to be a doctor, lawyer, CPA, something like that,” he says, laughing. Lawrence studied art and biology at Dartmouth, worked summers at Christie’s, then took graduate courses at the Cooper Hewitt. Eventually, though, he ruled out a career in the auction-gallery world and instead began working for designers: first Paul Siskin, then Thom Filicia. In 2006, he started his own design business with a single client. Soon enough, referrals put it on solid footing.
The house has plenty of room for the couple’s three cats and Lawrence’s taxidermy and shell collections, not to mention his “constantly growing” menagerie of mid-century toy monkeys. It all reminds him a bit of his childhood in Trinidad, where his grandfather had a garden filled with creatures great and small, including parrots, mongooses, ducks, chickens, dogs, cats, and monkeys, and a pond full of guppies from the river nearby. “I never really thought about how fortunate we were to have that,” Lawrence says. “I think a lot of it was for the entertainment of me and my sister.”
The revamped kitchen, which they chose to leave in its original location rather than move up to the parlor floor, is the latest in a series of considered updates. “One of the things we bought when we moved in was a full refrigerator, and we had to take the bars off the window to get it into the kitchen. I was like, We’re never doing that again,” he says. Hence the appliances are under-counter, including the fridge and freezer drawers, and there is a large island and an alcove banquette seating area.
But just to be clear, “I absolutely hate cooking,” Lawrence says. And so Sonterre “gets to organize it anyway he wants.”
The Living Room: The tapestry, The Fall of Icarus (1959), by Jan Yoors, is flanked by a Danish teak-and-cord lounge chair (ca. 1960) and a mid-century planter from Architectural Pottery filled with ostrich eggs.
The Bedroom: Lawrence has been collecting these mid-century toy monkeys since he first moved to the city more than 25 years ago. The ’60s floor lamp is by Robert Sonneman.
The Dining Room: Two ’50s walnut-and-brass standing lamps flank the vintage ebonized Saarinen table by Knoll. “I found both lamps at the Chelsea flea market 20 years apart,” he says. “I was not looking for a second one at all.” The mid-century owls on the mantelpiece are Curtis Jere, and the hanging light fixture is by Lindsey Adelman.
The Collection: Lawrence devoted a room to his vintage taxidermy. “I would never get anything that is new,” he notes. The pieces are mostly from flea markets and antique stores; some items were deaccessioned by the American Museum of Natural History (the head is a wax cast).
The New Bathroom: A storage room off the kitchen is now a bathroom; the tiled walls are topped with a frieze made of Bakelite shaving brushes. The white mosaic penny tiles on the floor are from Nemo. The ceramic arm sconce is by C.J. Piere.
The Eat-In Kitchen: The renovation of the kitchen included taking out counter space to create the banquette seating area, which includes a Knoll Saarinen table and a 1920s industrial metal stool. The Parzinger-style lotus light fixture is by Feldman Lighting.
The Kitchen: The new appliances are all under the counter, and the stove rests on the slab where cooking has been done since the house was built.
The Living Room: The tapestry, The Fall of Icarus (1959), by Jan Yoors, is flanked by a Danish teak-and-cord lounge chair (ca. 1960) and a mid-century planter from Architectural Pottery filled with ostrich eggs.
The Bedroom: Lawrence has been collecting these mid-century toy monkeys since he first moved to the city more than 25 years ago. The ’60s floor lamp is by Robert Sonneman.
The Dining Room: Two ’50s walnut-and-brass standing lamps flank the vintage ebonized Saarinen table by Knoll. “I found both lamps at the Chelsea flea market 20 years apart,” he says. “I was not looking for a second one at all.” The mid-century owls on the mantelpiece are Curtis Jere, and the hanging light fixture is by Lindsey Adelman.
The Collection: Lawrence devoted a room to his vintage taxidermy. “I would never get anything that is new,” he notes. The pieces are mostly from flea markets and antique stores; some items were deaccessioned by the American Museum of Natural History (the head is a wax cast).
The New Bathroom: A storage room off the kitchen is now a bathroom; the tiled walls are topped with a frieze made of Bakelite shaving brushes. The white mosaic penny tiles on the floor are from Nemo. The ceramic arm sconce is by C.J. Piere.
The Eat-In Kitchen: The renovation of the kitchen included taking out counter space to create the banquette seating area, which includes a Knoll Saarinen table and a 1920s industrial metal stool. The Parzinger-style lotus light fixture is by Feldman Lighting.
The Kitchen: The new appliances are all under the counter, and the stove rests on the slab where cooking has been done since the house was built.
More Great Rooms
- The Selby’s New Book About Creatives With Kids at Home
- ‘If I Had to Leave This Place, I Would Probably Leave New York’
- I’ll Never Forget the Apartment Gaetano Pesce Did for Ruth Shuman
